Fireclean, aka Crisco?

Faktory 47

Willy Leadwell

Purveyor of Polyurethane
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 26, 2015
2,159
1,679
113
Loganville, GA
Zip code
30052
So, I've been doing a little more reading on this topic over the last few days. It turns out that straight veggie oil or canola oil are NOT the same as Fireclean. Short version, they spoil and turn rancid quickly, stinking to high heaven. Fireclean is most certainly a vegetable or seed based oil, most likely a combination of oils. No one knows yet if there are any additives used. So, it does appear that the makers of FC actually did their homework and developed a unique product. Veggie based, non-toxic oils are becoming much more popular in industrial use and in some cases, do outperform petro based lubes. Here's my cliff notes posted on another site.
PAM is just a blend of oils with silicone added to keep it from gelling up. So maybe fireclean = PAM???
 
  • Like
Reactions: Strider12

DarthVader

Marksman
Mar 25, 2015
1,175
390
113
Henry County
Zip code
30253
PAM is just a blend of oils with silicone added to keep it from gelling up. So maybe fireclean = PAM???
No idea, but I doubt it. PAM will cook down to a sticky residue on a baking sheet at less than 375°. FC has stated that they don't use soybean oil, so anything containing soybeans is out also. Whatever they are using doesn't appear to be a repackaged off the shelf oil. It appears to be a unique blend of three different vegetable or seed based oils. That means that they actually did the R&D, and found a formula that worked. It's no different than a motor oil company developing a new blend.

This whole thing blew up because of how The Firearm Blog titled their repost of Andrew Tuohy's original article. TFB used the comparison to Crisco, not the original author. In fact, he has clearly stated that FC is an effective lube and it does what they claim. But that's not what the Internet pays attention to. So far, there's no evidence to indict Fireclean as to its efficacy. The only valid complaint is that it's more expensive than others on the market. If you think it's too expensive, just use something else. Simple.

To the point of whether or not FC is something as simple as canola oil, a couple of guys have already tried experimenting with it. The guns ran fine, but within a couple of days the oil had gone rancid, stunk badly and gummed up into a sludge after use. Fireclean does none of those things.

On the other hand, the smoke test still seems shady. But LAV has stated that they were using reloads.

I'll keep using the supply I have until I run out. The main reasons are that it really does work well, doesn't burn off as fast as others, more or less stays where you put it, doesn't gum up like other popular non-toxic lubes and it's non-toxic. That's important to me because I usually shoot suppressed and I don't really want to breathe in vaporized motor oil or ATF.
 

Sheps

Woodsman
Jun 24, 2015
137
80
43
www.youtube.com
Zip code
en5 1ae
Ok so Fireclean isn't just Canola oil, we've known that from the start. But. What has been proven now is that rather than spend $15 on a lil lube we can go buy a gallon of olive oil or some Crisco or whatever and have something to cook with and lube our sh!t with.

That is if you weren't already using your left over motor oil or grease from when you service your car.
 

PewPewPewCo

Sniper
Mar 23, 2015
2,139
1,075
113
Georgia
There was always an understanding that it was processed. Fire clean doesn't spoil. He question is how different is it, obviously enough that using crisco seems damaging to finishes, probably due to Ph level/acidity since nickel boron doesn't like acid from what I've read.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarthVader

Laufen

Beloved flaming retard
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 23, 2015
7,927
6,129
113
I85
Zip code
30030
Is this thread still going?

Read the patent y'all.
 

DarthVader

Marksman
Mar 25, 2015
1,175
390
113
Henry County
Zip code
30253
Ok so Fireclean isn't just Canola oil, we've known that from the start. But. What has been proven now is that rather than spend $15 on a lil lube we can go buy a gallon of olive oil or some Crisco or whatever and have something to cook with and lube our sh!t with.

That is if you weren't already using your left over motor oil or grease from when you service your car.
Not sure if you read the linked thread, but that doesn't work. Cooking oils, so far, have been shown to develop a bad odor and leave behind a sticky residue. Fireclean does not exhibit these behaviors.
There was always an understanding that it was processed. Fire clean doesn't spoil. He question is how different is it, obviously enough that using crisco seems damaging to finishes, probably due to Ph level/acidity since nickel boron doesn't like acid from what I've read.
Right. The only reason I posted the update was in an attempt to dispel the quickly growing myth that it's simple off the shelf canola or vegetable oil. As Laufen alluded, the patent indicates that it is likely a blend of up to three different bio-oils. The company has been portrayed as if they simply rebottled an off the shelf product. But evidence is mounting that this isn't the case. Granted, the raw materials are likely very inexpensive compared to the product cost. But the guys that developed it, apparently did spend some time doing actual research and testing in order to determine what formulation actually works.

It's really no different than how other companies develop petroleum based lubricants. They haven't exactly reinvented the wheel.
 

Red Dawn

Wolverines
Site Supporter
Lifetime Supporter
Aug 12, 2015
5,743
6,957
113
H Town
Zip code
30228
I use FireClean on my baffles in my suppressor and it is 10xs easier to clean than without.