S&W 686 vs Ruger GP100

Southeast Traders Apparel Swag Store

AtlMedic

Not A Doctor
Mar 25, 2015
2,644
1,441
113
Smyrna, GA
Zip code
30082
I know this is similar to the Ford vs Chevy or 870 vs 500 debates.

I need a woods gun, my in-laws farm has a lot of snakes and with my son being more adventurous I want to have a good way to drop one and my glocks won't cycle snake shot.

So between the 686 and the GP100 which do y'all prefer and why.

Both would be in .357 and stainless. Price is similar. I know the smith has a better trigger but for my needs the ruger would do just fine.
 

Jake

Steering wheel holder
Super Moderator
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Aug 11, 2015
8,361
36,820
113
Ball Ground
Zip code
30189
SP-101, LCR or j frame. Then you'd have something that you can carry if you wanted to as well.
 

AtlMedic

Not A Doctor
Mar 25, 2015
2,644
1,441
113
Smyrna, GA
Zip code
30082
SP-101, LCR or j frame. Then you'd have something that you can carry if you wanted to as well.
Eh, I'd rather something large enough to shoot .357 comfortably. I have glocks for carry. This would be for range, hunting back up, and walking around the woods.
 

DMR

CZ Fan
Jun 4, 2015
812
577
113
Snellville
Zip code
30078
686 > gp100

Or a Dan Wesson 15VH whenever possible.

I've had many Rugers and Smiths, but in the end, the Smith just feels better and looks better. The GP would be my 2nd choice if I had no choice. Not because the GP is worse...oh no, the GP100 in many retrospects is the better built gun. I also like Smiths 7 shot version.

http://www.gunbroker.com/item/609244674
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: AtlMedic

AtlMedic

Not A Doctor
Mar 25, 2015
2,644
1,441
113
Smyrna, GA
Zip code
30082
686 > gp100

Or a Dan Wesson 15VH whenever possible.

I've had many Rugers and Smiths, but in the end, the Smith just feels better and looks better. The GP would be my 2nd choice if I had no choice. Not because the GP is worse...oh no, the GP100 in many retrospects is the better built gun. I also like Smiths 7 shot version.

http://www.gunbroker.com/item/609244674
Yeah when the time comes and if I go with the 686 I would probably buy the 7 shot if it's available. I'll probably run by the gun store and handle both. I've had a gp100 but it was years ago and I've had several J-frames but never a larger smith wheel gun.
 

Bottoms polaris

Raised in the 80’s
Sep 19, 2015
32
16
18
Northwest ga.
Zip code
30153
I have had both of these fine guns. Always went to the Ruger so I wound up selling the Smith to a buddy. Rugers are built like tanks. Ruger has came out with an 8 shot snubby .357 also. Got to ge me one.
 

Waterguy

Woodsman
Trusted Trader
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 26, 2015
223
113
113
North Georgia
Zip code
30114
I have had both of these fine guns. Always went to the Ruger so I wound up selling the Smith to a buddy. Rugers are built like tanks. Ruger has came out with an 8 shot snubby .357 also. Got to ge me one.

I agree. The Ruger will never wear out. I handload my rounds and I have put some HOT stuff in it and no problems whatsoever. Matter of fact the hot loads shot better in it. Nothing against a Smith but I choose the Ruger.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AtlMedic

Rwjeter

Space Force General Freeze.
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Nov 16, 2016
5,354
10,815
113
Temple
Zip code
30179
Just curious, but why not a Governor or a Judge? That's what I always carried for snakes. A titanium Public Defender to be specific. Lightweight, recoil was mild enough, .410 did the job.
 

Waterguy

Woodsman
Trusted Trader
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 26, 2015
223
113
113
North Georgia
Zip code
30114
20161230_151427.jpg 20161230_151523.jpg

Here is my setup. GP100 triple k holster. Some speer deep curl handloads. I got two speed strips in my pocket.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rwjeter

AtlMedic

Not A Doctor
Mar 25, 2015
2,644
1,441
113
Smyrna, GA
Zip code
30082
Just curious, but why not a Governor or a Judge? That's what I always carried for snakes. A titanium Public Defender to be specific. Lightweight, recoil was mild enough, .410 did the job.
I just really don't like those guns. Plus a good .357 is always a good thing to have. The .410 pistols are just gimmicks to me.
 

Rwjeter

Space Force General Freeze.
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Nov 16, 2016
5,354
10,815
113
Temple
Zip code
30179
I just really don't like those guns. Plus a good .357 is always a good thing to have. The .410 pistols are just gimmicks to me.
They do typically look pretty goofy. And ballistically speaking not the best for defense, but I always liked them for the woods. A Smith model 66 was my first hand gun though so I'm also partial to the .357. I'd love a J Frame .357 to add to my carry rotation. I'd say it's a toss up between the two though. Both are great. Especially if you look at Pre lock.
 

Jake

Steering wheel holder
Super Moderator
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Aug 11, 2015
8,361
36,820
113
Ball Ground
Zip code
30189
I have had both of these fine guns. Always went to the Ruger so I wound up selling the Smith to a buddy. Rugers are built like tanks. Ruger has came out with an 8 shot snubby .357 also. Got to ge me one.

An 8 shot? You got a link? I tried to Google it but my Google Fu is weak.
 

Hayata

Blam-blam-blam-blam-blam-blam-blam-blam-PING!
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Jul 5, 2015
6,135
30,134
113
Zip code
30022
I love my 686. Put a spring kit in it and wow, what a difference!

Pistolas 140.jpg

Good luck with your choice!
 
  • Like
Reactions: mikey357 and Jake

Jake

Steering wheel holder
Super Moderator
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Aug 11, 2015
8,361
36,820
113
Ball Ground
Zip code
30189
They do typically look pretty goofy. And ballistically speaking not the best for defense, but I always liked them for the woods. A Smith model 66 was my first hand gun though so I'm also partial to the .357. I'd love a J Frame .357 to add to my carry rotation. I'd say it's a toss up between the two though. Both are great. Especially if you look at Pre lock.

I love my LCR 357. It is pretty much the perfect carry revolver. They have the best triggers of any of the small wheel guns I've ever had, including a S&W 442 with an apex spring kit. Shooting .357's out of it is a breeze too.
 

Rwjeter

Space Force General Freeze.
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Nov 16, 2016
5,354
10,815
113
Temple
Zip code
30179
I love my LCR 357. It is pretty much the perfect carry revolver. They have the best triggers of any of the small wheel guns I've ever had, including a S&W 442 with an apex spring kit. Shooting .357's out of it is a breeze too.
I just like hammers on revolvers though. Lol