Econ 529 college savings

GA Firing Line

EugenFJR

An anchor on a ship of fools.
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Jul 3, 2015
4,564
16,321
113
Your mom's house
Zip code
90210
I not saying this to be a smart ass, but I'd strongly encourage your kids to join the Army and get a huge signing bonus and $40,000.00 for college, maybe even more. I'm looking at going back for a masters in history, and I can't believe how stupid expensive it is now.
 

Hayata

Blam-blam-blam-blam-blam-blam-blam-blam-PING!
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Jul 5, 2015
6,135
30,134
113
Zip code
30022
I have one for each boy - fraternal twins. I have the things set up so they suck money out of my checking account every month. It's also set up so it's less aggressive/risky in investing the closer the boys get to entering college.

And I'm going to piggy-back what @EugenFJR said - school is stupid expensive right now. I was really hoping to get them through without a boat load of debt but maybe half a boat load at this point.

Will definitely consider the Army for son #2 who wants to be an anesthesiologist. I can't even imagine how much an education like that would cost. Son #1 wants to be a mechanical engineer so at least I think once they graduate they will be employable.

Is the 529 the best route? I dunno, I'm not a money guy so it fits the bill for us because it's automatic and the gains are protected against tax.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DoglegArms

Laufen

Beloved flaming retard
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 23, 2015
7,927
6,129
113
I85
Zip code
30030
I not saying this to be a smart ass, but I'd strongly encourage your kids to join the Army and get a huge signing bonus and $40,000.00 for college, maybe even more. I'm looking at going back for a masters in history, and I can't believe how stupid expensive it is now.
It's not for everyone, and I sure wouldn't want that to be my only plan.
 

EugenFJR

An anchor on a ship of fools.
Kalash Klub
Lifetime Supporter
Jul 3, 2015
4,564
16,321
113
Your mom's house
Zip code
90210
It's not for everyone, and I sure wouldn't want that to be my only plan.

There's also the Air Force, Navy and Marines... A few years in service gives you huge advantages, not just money for college, but VA loans, etc. are just a few of the advantages of serving in the armed forces. It's a lot better than graduating from college, with the crushing weight of debt from loans.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DoglegArms

Laufen

Beloved flaming retard
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 23, 2015
7,927
6,129
113
I85
Zip code
30030
There's also the Air Force, Navy and Marines... A few years in service gives you huge advantages, not just money for college, but VA loans, etc. are just a few of the advantages of serving in the armed forces. It's a lot better than graduating from college, with the crushing weight of debt from loans.
Yeah, but again, that path isn't for everyone. I do agree with taking a break between HS and college. The German system of military service for two years, or an apprenticeship/volunteer work makes a lot of sense.

For instance, military service is not at all what I needed or wanted upon graduating. I had enough authoritarianism at home while growing up, if anything I needed less structure and a chance to figure out what I actually wanted for my life, not just continue the slave/servant relationship that I had while growing up on the farm.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DoglegArms

1776

World Class Dick Wrangler
Site Supporter
Kalash Klub
Sep 5, 2015
3,590
8,600
113
Da SAV
Zip code
31401
There's also the Air Force, Navy and Marines... A few years in service gives you huge advantages, not just money for college, but VA loans, etc. are just a few of the advantages of serving in the armed forces. It's a lot better than graduating from college, with the crushing weight of debt from loans.
You forgot the puddle pirates........they're nothing like the military, but you still get all the benefits. Seriously, the few I know all agree, CG is just a job that happens to have a uniform for the majority of them
 

Cudruln

Turning dollars into pennies.
Lifetime Supporter
Jul 5, 2015
4,337
4,579
113
Rockmart, GA
Zip code
30153
I will say it.

Screw college and get to work.

That's what I did and turned out decent.

But I do have a fund for the kids set up. Honestly have no idea exactly what it is though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leshaire and 1776

Allsmiles

Frontiersman
Site Supporter
Kalash Klub
Mar 15, 2017
335
517
93
Golfcart City, GA
Zip code
30269
We did the FL prepaid collage program when we lived there. We paid school tuition and got reimburses for part of that. It was taxed as a 529. Might check and see if you ha e any relatives in FL and start making payments. We started when the kids we 2 and 4 and paid about $5800 (over 5 years) each for their schooling. About a new car payment back in the day
 

Leshaire

Weekend Warrior
Mar 27, 2015
3,343
1,994
113
Acworth
Zip code
30102
Anyone use a 529 for college savings? Is this the best route?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Yes and yes. Read up on it. Easy to contribute, federal tax deferred, can be spent on other people if your indicated kid doesn't go to college, can be used on a HUGE list of things including high school, books, and tons of other education related items. I opened one for my son and dumped a few grand in it day one and contribute monthly auto from my bank account. If the market does ABSOLUTELY NOTHING for 18 years I will still have a reasonable ~25K for him. But we know that won't happen. As I get raises I plan to up to monthly contribution too.

Pretty sure if all else fails you can just pay the federal tax on your earnings and still take it out for whatever you want...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DoglegArms

Jcountry

Frontiersman
Mar 30, 2015
350
194
93
Georgia
I will say it.

Screw college and get to work.

That's what I did and turned out decent.

But I do have a fund for the kids set up. Honestly have no idea exactly what it is though.


Depends on what your kids want to do/are good at.

Some college degrees are obviously pointless and worthless.

Others re awesome and lead to an incredible job.

I have always thought it would be good to give a kid the opportunity to go as far as they can. For some it's tech school (which is good) for others, they might win a Nobel prize or come up with something that can change lives. For those, there is no path other than college.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cudruln

DaBlock

Woodsman
Lifetime Supporter
Mar 31, 2015
129
53
93
Raleigh, NC
Zip code
27606
Yes, "do eet," on the 529. Tax deferred means the effective tax paid will be on them in the lowest bracket (most likely) when they need it. The habit of saving a bit often (over time) reduces the felt impact to you/them vs a bod outlay. If you have friends/family have them make contributions a bit when they can.
 

Cudruln

Turning dollars into pennies.
Lifetime Supporter
Jul 5, 2015
4,337
4,579
113
Rockmart, GA
Zip code
30153
Depends on what your kids want to do/are good at.

Some college degrees are obviously pointless and worthless.

Others re awesome and lead to an incredible job.

I have always thought it would be good to give a kid the opportunity to go as far as they can. For some it's tech school (which is good) for others, they might win a Nobel prize or come up with something that can change lives. For those, there is no path other than college.
My oldest is smart enough to pursue a college degree. But if he actually applies himself to do so is another thing. Now my second kid is another breed, he is wild and out currently, but seems to be decently smart at almost 3.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jcountry

Leshaire

Weekend Warrior
Mar 27, 2015
3,343
1,994
113
Acworth
Zip code
30102
Depends on what your kids want to do/are good at.

Some college degrees are obviously pointless and worthless.

Others re awesome and lead to an incredible job.

I have always thought it would be good to give a kid the opportunity to go as far as they can. For some it's tech school (which is good) for others, they might win a Nobel prize or come up with something that can change lives. For those, there is no path other than college.
The problem with this idea is that you should be prepared and working on this long before a decision like that can reasonably be made. The purpose of the 529 is TIME in the market. If you wait until they are 15 or 16 and have a reasonable idea of what they want to do, it's too late to start saving for a college degree.
 

Jcountry

Frontiersman
Mar 30, 2015
350
194
93
Georgia
The problem with this idea is that you should be prepared and working on this long before a decision like that can reasonably be made. The purpose of the 529 is TIME in the market. If you wait until they are 15 or 16 and have a reasonable idea of what they want to do, it's too late to start saving for a college degree.


There's always loans.....

If the degree is in anything worthwhile, the investment will be a wise one.

Also, the tax advantages of most states' 529s are pretty substantial.

Anyone looking at college should also apply for any scholarships they can. Several thousand per year go unawarded.

I get what folks are saying. College isn't for everyone. Some people are better suited for technical stuff, and the military can be a good way to get some skills and get the GI bill..... Or do college ROTC. My uncle did that, and the military paid for his college and his advanced degrees and licenses.

People also should consider co-op. Seems to be overlooked for some reason, but a co-op program where someone goes to school on the side and works part time is an excellent opportunity. When that person gets their degree, it will come with real work experience, and that is often the hardest part.

My entire college debt was $9800. I graduated in '93. I was making 10x that amount within a decade, and I'm thankful to be making a good bit more now. I definitely would not be where I am without a degree.

The way I look at college is it will be what a kid makes out of it. A great opportunity which some squander by smoking enough pot to kill a horse, and others take full advantage of to really improve their lives and set the next generation up for success. It's an awesome opportunity for those who take it seriously.

The best advice though..... Degrees or not, military or civilian background: You get paid for what you can do. No where you went, or who you know. Your skill set is your product. A lot of people think that a big-name school will make it easier to get a job. Nope. A big skill set will.
 
Last edited:

Leshaire

Weekend Warrior
Mar 27, 2015
3,343
1,994
113
Acworth
Zip code
30102
There's always loans.....

If the degree is in anything worthwhile, the investment will be a wise one.

Also, the tax advantages of most states' 529s are pretty substantial.

Anyone looking at college should also apply for any scholarships they can. Several thousand per year go unawarded.

I get what folks are saying. College isn't for everyone. Some people are better suited for technical stuff, and the military can be a good way to get some skills and get the GI bill..... Or do college ROTC. My uncle did that, and the military paid for his college and his advanced degrees and licenses.

People also should consider co-op. Seems to be overlooked for some reason, but a co-op program where someone goes to school on the side and works part time is an excellent opportunity. When that person gets their degree, it will come with real work experience, and that is often the hardest part.

My entire college debt was $9800. I graduated in '93. I was making 10x that amount within a decade, and I'm thankful to be making a good bit more now. I definitely would not be where I am without a degree.

The way I look at college is it will be what a kid makes out of it. A great opportunity which some squander by smoking enough pot to kill a horse, and others take full advantage of to really improve their lives and set the next generation up for success. It's an awesome opportunity for those who take it seriously.

The best advice though..... Degrees or not, military or civilian background: You get paid for what you can do. No where you went, or who you know. Your skill set is your product. A lot of people think that a big-name school will make it easier to get a job. Nope. A big skill set will.
Don't get me wrong, I have two degrees I am still paying for with about 11K to go. My parents weren't prepared for me to go to college so I am paying for it now. For someone to wait until his/her child is almost of age and then try to start saving is simply naive. Sure there are loans, but as an adult that chose to have a child, it'd be more worth your money to start saving early by an extremely far margin.

If your child's degree will cost 50K and you saved 25K in a 529 and doubled your money in the market in 18 years, your investment would be 25K (doubling money in the market in the last 18 years is nearly child's play). On top of that, you had 25K in tax deferred income. If you waited until college time and took 50K in loans then pay 5.05% (current going rate for undergrad loans) over the next 10 years, you'll be paying $531.55 a MONTH and pay a total of $63,786.05. And don't forget the 25 ish percent you're paying for each one of those dollars in income tax as well. Ends up more like $79,732.56. Seems pretty clear to me that it is worth the couple bucks a paycheck...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1776

1776

World Class Dick Wrangler
Site Supporter
Kalash Klub
Sep 5, 2015
3,590
8,600
113
Da SAV
Zip code
31401
A great opportunity which some squander by smoking enough pot to kill a horse,
How much pot would it take to kill a horse?
The estimates for lethal toxicity in humans are ridiculous.....1200+mg thc per kg body weight. You'd have to smoke a literal ton of weed in a very short period of time to have a shot at OD'ing.
I think you'd be better off just trying to crush the horse with the weight of the weed....it'd likely require less.
 

Mac11FA

Disgruntled large member
Super Moderator
Lifetime Supporter
Patriot Lifetime
Mar 26, 2015
3,840
3,011
113
Locust Grove, GA
Zip code
30248
How much pot would it take to kill a horse?
The estimates for lethal toxicity in humans are ridiculous.....1200+mg thc per kg body weight. You'd have to smoke a literal ton of weed in a very short period of time to have a shot at OD'ing.
I think you'd be better off just trying to crush the horse with the weight of the weed....it'd likely require less.
Depends on the horse...

Sorta like "What is the average air speed velocity of a laden swallow? "

“What do you mean, an African or European Swallow?”

Monty Python fans...
 
  • Like
Reactions: lesptr

Jcountry

Frontiersman
Mar 30, 2015
350
194
93
Georgia
How much pot would it take to kill a horse?
The estimates for lethal toxicity in humans are ridiculous.....1200+mg thc per kg body weight. You'd have to smoke a literal ton of weed in a very short period of time to have a shot at OD'ing.
I think you'd be better off just trying to crush the horse with the weight of the weed....it'd likely require less.


Seems a lot like the kind of question one comes up with when one gets really baked....

(Followed shortly by "I got the munchies, man...." )